|
THE BURNING BUSH
Volume 9 Number 2, July
2003
FILIAL PIETY AND BURIAL CUSTOMS
Tan Eng Boo
Statement of Problem
Chinese Christians in a non-Christian
home often face the dilemma of what they should do on occasions of death
and burial in the family. The situation can be so complicated at times. As
such, it is needful for this matter to be handled with extreme care and
sensitivity. Dr Poh Boon Seng says,
Many
Christians are so blissfully ignorant of the significance of various
rites carried out during a Chinese funeral. When a death occurs in the
family, he is caught off guard and does not know what to do. There are
also times when he has to attend a funeral of a friend or a relative.
Then there is the annual All Souls Day when he is faced with the various
rites carried out by the family. 1
This article seeks to address these
issues so that Christians can be aware of what they should do, and be a
good witness and testimony for Jesus Christ. The Christian is to be the
salt and light of the earth (Matt 5:13-14). This paper also seeks to
provide alternatives as to how the church and her members can provide the
necessary help and comfort to the bereaved person.
The non-Christian Chinese, many of
whom are Buddhists, Confucianists or Taoists, are steeped in filial piety.
The loyalty and devotion of younger members of the family to their elders
is seen especially during the event of death. Every family member is
expected to perform a certain ritual for the deceased. Not to do so is
seen as a mark of disrespect, and causes one to be looked upon as an
unfilial son or daughter. It brings shame and disgrace to the family. This
is expressed in The Classic of Filial Piety: "The service of love
and reverence to parents when alive, and those of grief and sorrow to them
when dead. These completely discharged the fundamental duty of living
men." 2
The non-Christian Chinese also see the
performing of these rites as their final farewell and obligation to the
deceased. They wish for the deceased to have a happy life in the next
world, and hence, they will perform the rites. The ceremony, therefore, is
very important to them.
The Chinese Christian had better have
a correct understanding of Chinese rituals and their significance so that
they can deal with these issues wisely from a biblical standpoint.
Oftentimes, Chinese Christians compromise their faith by participating in
the funeral rites. One of the reasons could be a lack of biblical
instruction on this matter. Others may compromise because they do not
think that participation in these rituals is wrong for a Christian. There
are others who are pressurised to perform the rituals by their family and
relatives.
The loss of a loved one is a very
emotional experience. We have to be prepared for it and even be prepared
to counsel church members before the event. Not to do so would be
detrimental to our Christian faith and testimony. We are to do all things
to the glory of God (1 Cor 10:31).
The Significance of Filial Piety
and Burial Customs
Filial piety is one of the virtues of
man. Chinese culture places a great deal of emphasis on this matter. To
the Chinese, filial piety is a religious or quasi-religious practice. It
is said, "The Chinese family is the crux of society, so the family is the
orbit around which religion revolves, ancestor veneration is the centre of
that family religion." 3 Even
in death, the ancestors’ spirits are regularly acknowledged by the living.
Family members will show their respect to the dead by "performing rituals
and other spoken tributes, leaving gifts or sending them off by burning
paper and other materials. Ancestors, if not worshipped, are at least
highly revered."4
It has been said that there are three
ways in which a son can show his filial piety to his parents:
Feed them
while they live, mourn for them when they die, and offer sacrifice to
them after they die. In feeding, the important thing is obedience; in
mourning, it is the sadness; and in sacrifice, the respect. When one has
done these three, one can rightly be called a filial son. 5
Failure to perform these rituals only
constitutes a lack of respect for the deceased. One of Confucius’
followers, Hsun Tzu, explained that such
rites are
the expression of man’s will, emotion, remembrance, and love. They
represent the height of loyalty, faithfulness, love, and respect…. With
sorrow and reverence, one serves the dead as he serves the living, and
serves the departed as he serves those present. What is served has
neither appearance nor shadow, and yet the social order is completed in
this way. 6
Why is this act so important to the
Chinese? It is important because it is a fulfillment of human
relationship. Confucius said, "To serve those now dead as if they were
living, and those departed as if they were still with us: this is the
highest achievement of true filial piety." 7
These rituals have always been an
important feature in Chinese culture because they are a show of what it
means to be a filial person to the deceased. As Chinese Christians, we
must always be mindful of this aspect. However, we must not compromise our
Christian testimony by performing these rituals with them (Matt 5:14). For
us Christians, we also believe that the deceased has either gone to heaven
or hell after death (Heb 9:27; Luke16:22-23).
The Rituals and their Religious
Significance
The traditional Chinese believe that
the soul of the deceased must make its way to the "Western Heaven" after
death. Many rituals are conducted by family members to assist the deceased
in this journey. According to Chinese belief, all souls, good or bad have
to be present at the purgatory Yamen at the time of death. The good
ones may go directly to the Western heaven after a tour of purgatory. In
Taoist belief, "The deceased person must go down to hell and be judged
according to the way he lived in this world, whether he did good or evil.
He must go through ten halls and receive ten different judgments." 8 Naturally,
children do not wish for their departed parents to suffer too much in hell
or remain there for too long. So they arrange for an elaborate religious
ritual and ceremony so as to appease the gods and persuade them to be
lenient to their ancestors.
While there are many rituals in the
Chinese funeral, we will only look at some common ones. These are
religious in nature and tainted with superstitions. Let the Christian stay
out of these rituals (2 Cor 6:16).
Washing and Clothing the Deceased
The sons of the deceased perform this
ritual by symbolically wiping the body of the deceased three times with
water. This ritual is important because according to Chinese belief, "a
person with an unclean body will be despised and punished in Hell." After
the washing, the deceased is dressed. Some personal belongings are also
placed in the coffin for use in the afterlife. A pearl (today it is
usually a coin to bribe the official of the next world or a grain of rice
to ensure that the dead would never grow hungry) is placed in the mouth of
the deceased to ensure a smooth journey. Coins are put in the person’s
left hand for paying the guardian spirit. Shoes are put on the person’s
feet to prepare for the long journey.
Christians should not participate in
these superstitious rituals. We believe that the dead at death enters
heaven if the person is a believer (2 Cor 5:8). God shall comfort the
Christian for the afterlife is a life with God in heaven (Luke 16:25, 2
Cor 5:1).
Presentation of Food and Paper
Money
Although these rituals are elaborate
in varying degrees, the basic items are rice, some meat dishes, incense
and paper money. The Chinese believe that, "the offering of food and joss
paper signifies the continuing interdependence between the living
descendants and the dead relative." 9
It is believed that "paper-money is often offered today as an attempt to
"bribe" the spirits (i.e., the hungry ghosts, so that they would not harm
us and also to win merit for our ancestors; and our ancestors, so that
they would bless us)."10 A dual purpose is seen here as the
living also seek to be protected from such spirits, but more so, the
offering is done for the deceased as it is "offered to make the journey
easier for the departed soul. Paper money is scattered on the road to buy
the goodwill of malicious, wandering spirits, that they may not molest the
wrath of the deceased on its way to the grave."11
Christians should not get involved in
this matter of offering paper money to the deceased. The dead and the
living do not have any contact (2 Sam 12:23). The spirits of the departed
cannot return to harm us (Heb 9:27). We need not fear any evil spirit (Rom
8:31). Christians should also abstain from folding paper money etc. (1
Thess 5:22). This is not their job. Other forms of help can be rendered
instead.
Religious Service
The religious service is an elaborate
one. The ceremony is usually conducted by Buddhist or Taoist monks and all
the mourners are expected to participate. This is a religious rite "during
which the soul of the deceased is supposed to be led through its journey
into the spirit-world." 12
The eldest son must carry the urn of joss sticks (or lantern) and follow
the priest to represent the dead, being guided to "heaven" by the priest.
The son plays an important role in performing this required ritual.
Confucius taught that male heirs could only perform the funeral rites:
For this
reason, the Chinese consider it most unfilial not to produce sons. The
absence of male heirs will mean the end of the worship of the whole line
of ancestors, which will be disastrous. As a result, non-Christian
parents adamantly opposed to their sons, especially their eldest sons,
being baptised. Baptism will mean the end of ancestral worship. It would
be the same as not having sons and is therefore considered most
unfilial. 13
If you are the eldest son in a
non-Christian family, you may face a severe opposition to your faith,
especially when it comes to your baptism. Be prepared for it.
During such religious services,
prayers are also chanted to appease any spirit that may seek to hinder the
deceased on his journey. Prayers and incantations are also made to enable
the deceased to cross the bridges. Incense must be lit to the bridge god
at every bridge for permission to cross the bridge. Permission must be
sought from the god of the earth for burial.
As Christians, we should never get
involved in any of these religious rituals. We must stay out of anything
that has to do with the monk leading the way. This is no time to be
emotional. If we follow the monk, we are saying that we agree with him in
all that he is doing. There is no agreement between the temple of God with
idols (2 Cor 6:16).
Holding a Funeral Wake
This is done so as to allow for
relatives and friends to visit the family and pay their last respects to
the deceased. The wake may last from three to seven days. During this
period, many rituals are performed.
One of the most significant rituals
during the wake is for people to come before the altar of the deceased and
pay their respects. Most people would bow before the altar or photo of the
deceased. They would do so with a lighted joss-stick and they would bow
three times. Some people bow without any joss-stick. This is a form of
worship of the dead! The Rev Dr Timothy Tow says, "to bow to the dead is a
form of worship, like bowing to ancestral tablets and family idols." Let
me also quote what Dr Poh Boon Sing has to say about this matter:
In the
Bible, bowing involves kneeling or prostrating oneself to the ground,
and not just stooping the head while standing. A progression from the
Old Testament to the New Testament may be noticed, in which bowing
becomes increasingly associated with worship. (Matt 4:9, Mark 15:19). In
the Bible, the number of occasions of bowing to God and the Lord Jesus
Christ is far more than the cases of bowing to creatures. Godly
individuals always forbade others to bow down to them (Esth 3:1-5, Acts
10:25-26, Rev 19:9-10, 22:8-9). From this we conclude that worship is
due only to God, and Christians must not bow to any persons. 14
If we want to show our respect, we can
always stand for a minute before the altar. There is no need for us to bow
before the altar or photo of the deceased.
It is always good for a Christian’s
testimony if he were to go straight to the altar to show respect for the
deceased when attending a wake. Let us not follow the non-Christian during
such time when "joss-sticks are burned to worship the dead and to make
contact with the soul of the deceased." 15
"The people who follow this custom know that this practice has this
meaning."16 Christians must not use joss-sticks at all. This
is not a matter of custom or culture but is religious in nature. We are
not to worship a person.
Band in a Funeral Procession
The funeral procession is normally
headed by a band of musicians. The music is meant to frighten away
malicious spirits lurking around the funeral site. They are also meant to
announce the arrival of the deceased to the spirit world and to bid him
into their midst. Such bands should not be employed in Christian funerals.
Christians should not adopt non-Christian rituals.
Some Related Superstitions
Visitors to the wake as well as to the
funeral are usually given a strand of red thread or small red packets
containing two coins to ensure that they get rid of any bad luck.
There are also several common items
served during such occasions because they are deemed to bring good luck to
everyone: "Sweets are served to remove the bitterness (bitter taste in the
mouth) of the loss. Groundnuts and melon seeds (commonly used to signify
fertility) is served so that the living might have more children to help
"replace" the loss." 17
Apart from the red thread, many people
today do not know the meaning and significance of the groundnuts, sweets
and melon seeds used at the wake. For most people, these edibles are
simply for consumption only. As Christians we do not need to take the red
threads or red packets offered to us because we are not superstitious. We
can politely refuse these things. If they are left on the table, we need
not take them.
What about the edible items? Should
they be eaten? This should not pose a problem if they have not been
offered to the idols. Eat them, but do not forget to give thanks to God
first (1 Tim 4:4-5).
Biblical Principles of Filial
Piety
For not participating in idolatrous or
superstitious rituals, the Christian is often criticised for being
unfilial. Many unbelieving Chinese are against the fact that the Bible
forbids ancestor worship. Many take this as a great offense against
Chinese culture. They cite verses like Matt 10:37, "He that loveth father
or mother more than me is not worthy of me," as proof text of their
charge. 18
Such an accusation is both unfair and
untrue. Filial piety is indeed taught in the Bible. In the days of Moses,
God commanded His people to honour their parents (Exod 20:12). The New
Testament also emphasises this teaching in Eph 6:1-3, "Children, obey your
parents in the Lord: for this is right. Honour thy father and mother;
(which is the first commandment with promise;) That is may be well with
thee, and thou mayest live long on the earth." Filial piety is not
something new to Christianity. It has been taught since the days of the
patriarchs in the Old Testament.
It must also be made clear that filial
piety must be seen in the light of children showing their love and care
for the elderly, their parents etc. while they are still alive. This is
the best way to prove our filial piety to our loved ones. In a famous
essay by Ou Yang Shieu, a noted scholar and statesmen in the Sung Dynasty,
he said,
It is more
important to provide respectfully and affectionately for the needs of
the parents when they are alive, rather than worship them by burning
paper money and spreading a feast before ancestral tablets which are
mere superstitious practices. 19
I remember conducting a funeral for a
Christian lady in June 1995 and encountering opposition from her eldest
son, who was not a Christian. He wanted to put some food for his deceased
mother, and offer paper money to her. I found out that this "filial son"
was never filial to his mother when she was alive. Now that she was gone,
he wanted to put on a show of filial piety to impress his friends and
relatives. There may have also been a sense of guilt that caused him to
act in this manner.
How can a Christian show his filial
piety to his parents? A Christian shows filial piety while his parents are
still alive. "A son honoureth his father" (Mal 1:6). Jesus said, "Honour
thy father and mother: and, He that curseth father or mother, let him die
the death" (Matt 15:4). "My son, keep thy father’s commandment, and
forsake not the law of thy mother" (Prov 6:20). The Bible pronounced a
curse on those who dishonour their parents. God was very serious about
this matter (Exod 21:15, 17; Lev 20:9; Prov 20:20, 30:17). Disrespect for
parents will bring punishment from God. "And he that smiteth his father,
or his mother, shall be surely put to death. And he that curseth his
father, or his mother, shall surely be put to death" (Exod 21:15, 17).
"The eye that mocketh at his father, and despiseth to obey his mother,
the ravens of the valley shall pick it out, and the young eagles shall eat
it (Prov 30:17).
Reverencing our parents is an act of
piety towards God for parents function as God’s representatives to
children on earth. 20 While
our parents are still alive and are able to enjoy our relationship with
them, we should take full advantage of this. They are the ones who brought
us into this world, nurtured and fed us and gave us good things in life.
How could we not honour them in return? "We honour them by being obedient
to them as far as possible, by caring for them and by consulting them when
making any major decisions. When such warm relationship exists, there will
be ample opportunity to witness to them about Jesus Christ. Too many
Christians, though concerned for the salvation of their parents, fail to
cultivate this warmth. As a consequence, they find it so difficult and
awkward to discuss spiritual things with them."21
There are a number of ways to show
filial piety. When our parents are still alive, give them due honour. Do
not humiliate them. Obey and honour them: "Whoso keepth the law is a wise
son: but he that is a companion of riotous men shameth his father" (Prov
28:7). Do not abuse them physically: "He that wasteth his father, and
chaseth away his mother, is a son that causeth shame, and bringeth
reproach" (Prov 19:26). The Bible says that the arrogant and rebellious
perform such disgraceful and shameful acts: "There is a generation that
curseth their father, and doth not bless their mother. There is a
generation that are pure in their own eyes, and yet is not washed from
their filthiness. There is a generation, O how lofty are their eyes! and
their eyelids are lifted up. There is a generation, whose teeth are as
swords, and their jaw teeth as knives, to devour the poor from off the
earth, and the needy from among men" (Prov 30:11-14).
When our parents are still alive, it
is the responsibility of children to feed and support them. Confucius
especially pointed out that "in feeding one’s parents, the important thing
is not the richness of the food, but the pleasure and happiness of the
parents." 22
Jesus set for us a good example. While
on the cross, He entrusted His earthly mother to the care of His disciple,
John (John 19:26-27). In the OT, we find Joseph taking care of his father
for 17 years when he was Prime Minister of Egypt. When his father died, he
personally brought his body back to Canaan for burial. Joseph "served his
father with respect when he lived, and buried him with respect when he
died." 23
When our parents are still alive, we
must exhort them gently. They are not sinless! Do not rebuke them openly
before others. "If a believer has unbelieving parents, he not only needs
to honour them, feed them, and not to disgrace them, but he must also
admonish them and lead them to the Lord. Helping one’s parents to walk in
the true way is one of the filial pious deeds." 24
When parents are still alive, be
thankful for them. The saddest thing is that when we want to express our
thankfulness to our parents, they may not be alive to receive it. Do it
now when they are still with us. Bring them out for lunch or dinner. We do
not have to wait until Father’s Day or Mother’s Day to do so. Dr. John
Davis said, "My grandmother used to say with some emphasis, ‘Don’t buy
flowers and visit me when I’m dead, do it when I’m alive so I can enjoy
it.’" 25
When they are gone, we remember them.
Filial piety is not measured by the pomp of the funeral or the luxury of
the gravesite sacrifice, but by the honour, glory, feeding, admonishing,
and thanksgiving one had been offering to parents while they were still
alive. After they die, we can only remember them, not worship them.
How should we remember our parents or
ancestors? Be like Joseph in Genesis 50, by giving our loved ones an
honourable funeral. We do not need to overspend, but we need to give our
loved ones a decent burial. We can also remember the anniversary of their
death. Publish a word of remembrance of the person in the newspapers.
Visit the grave to clean it, and to place flowers as a token of our love.
This may be done in the spring festival of Qing Ming (All Souls’
Day). This is an important occasion for the Chinese. This occasion
reinforces the ethic of filial piety. It is a major Chinese festival.
Before embarking on this trip to the
gravesite, Christians ought to talk to their loved ones to inform them
that they would want to do things like cleaning the gravesite, preparing
food and drinks for those who are going etc., but not perform any of the
religious rites. They must show their relatives that they love their
ancestors and do miss them too, but are not willing to compromise their
faith by going through the religious rites. Such gentle reminders show our
sincerity and sensitivity. When Christians display such faith and love,
unbelieving family members may be more sympathetic to the gospel message.
Necromancy: A False Filial Piety
Respect and honour to the living is
biblical, but communicating with the dead is not. Necromancy is forbidden
in the Scriptures. God commands in Deut 18:9-14,
When thou
art come into the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee, thou shalt
not learn to do after the abominations of those nations. There shall not
be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass
through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or
an enchanter, or a witch, Or a charmer, or a consulter with familiar
spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer. For all that do these things are
an abomination unto the LORD: and because of these abominations the LORD
thy God doth drive them out from before thee. Thou shalt be perfect with
the LORD thy God. For these nations, which thou shalt possess, hearkened
unto observers of times, and unto diviners: but as for thee, the LORD
thy God hath not suffered thee so to do.
Necromancy contains two ideas: "One
involves the worship of ancestors and the other is that the dead may be
consulted for purposes of determining the future." 26
This is done through a medium.
Zhong Yuan Jie, which is popularly
known as the Festival of the Hungry Ghost, falls around August. Similar to
Qing Ming, this festival is a time to think of the dead. "For the
Buddhist, this festival emphasizes filial piety. To the Taoist, this
festival includes prayers to the wandering souls throughout the world." 27
It is said that,
the Taoist believe that the graves
of hell are opened on the first day of the seventh month, allowing
unborn souls to wander the world for food and other necessities.
Throughout the month, food and joss papers are offered to these hungry
ghosts. 28
Most Chinese observe this occasion by
offering prayers, food, and paper money to the deceased. "The underlying
theme for such a festival is filial piety. It is a remembrance of one’s
loved ones and even friends." 29
The matter of necromancy comes in when the living have communion and
contact with the dead. Lest the deceased return with vengeance, the
Chinese believe that they must be in touch with the dead. Vengeful ghosts
are said to "have been abandoned by their living families."30
Necromancy is also the act of
contacting the dead for purposes of divination. "Such divination
presupposes that the dead are part of the family who has gone beyond death
into the spiritual realm. With spiritual realities, they become eyes of
the living to guide those who have not yet reach the other side." 31
"In other situations, necromancy employs dreams and visions, a common form
through which the dead communicate their wishes."32
The basic belief of the Chinese is
that the soul never dies and there is a continual relationship between the
living and the dead. This belief has led to ancestral worship and
necromancy. When a person dies, he is regarded by his family as a "god"
and is believed to be able to look after the welfare of the family.
Oftentimes, the family uses a medium
to communicate with the deceased to find out if he is happy, well fed and
well housed in Hades. "Mediums are often called in to help send offerings
to the deceased or even make special arrangements for their comfort." 33
"At other times the wishes of the dead are apparent only after evil has
occurred and when a diviner interprets the cause of the misfortune as
dissatisfaction of the dead with the living."34
The Bible forbids any contact with the
dead. As Christians, we must not have anything to do with necromancy. At
the moment of death, the dead goes to either heaven or hell (Luke
16:22-23). There can be no communication between the living and the dead
(Luke 16:27-31). The dead cannot come back to the world of the living,
even in a spirit form.
If it is impossible to communicate
with the deceased, then with whom are the mediums communicating? "Usually
when a medium calls up someone from the dead, it is a demonic deception:
that is a demon impersonating someone who is dead will begin to speak
through the medium." 35
Demons know the past history of the deceased. The devil is a master of
deception.
When a Christian is asked to
participate in a séance, he should explain to his loved ones the danger
and deception involved. If need be, the pastor or a mature Christian could
be invited to warn them of the dangers of such meetings through a study of
the Scriptures (Lev 19:31, 20:6, Deut 18:10-14, Isa 8:19).
While we want to be sensitive to our
loved ones and show our filial piety, we must never compromise our
beliefs. It is far better to communicate with the living now, than to wait
until they are gone and then seek to speak to them.
Conclusion
Chinese culture is steeped in filial
piety which often involves idolatry. Chinese Christians are often seen to
compromise their faith by participating in the many rituals. They need to
be instructed. It is imperative that they understand the requirements of
God, and seek to observe biblical principles in their lives. If Chinese
customs and culture infringe on biblical standards, we must, at all cost,
seek to honour God (1 Sam 2:30), and to obey His Word. We must also seek
to explain to our loved ones the reasons for our actions so that they
would not think that we are in any way unfilial.
Notes
1
Poh Boon Sing, The Christian in the Chinese Culture
(Malaysia: Good News Enterprise, 1986), 77.
2
Max Muller, ed, Sacred Books of the East, vol 3 (np: Krishna
Press, 1910), 448.
3
Keith W Hinton, Growing Churches Singapore Style (Singapore:
Overseas Missionary Fellowship, 1985), 44.
4
Philip M Steyne, Gods of Power (Houston: Touch Publications,
1990), 81.
5
Ibid., 87.
6
Vergilius Ferm, Religion in the Twentieth Century (New York:
Greenwood Press, 1948), 105
7
Ibid., 105.
8
Ardon Albrecht and Singi Go, A Guidebook for Christians on Taiwanese
Custom and Superstitions (Taipei: Taiwan, 1970), 100.
9
Steyne, Gods of Power, 127-8.
10
Daniel Tong, Ancestral Veneration (Singapore: The Christian
Library, 1993), 37.
11
C A S Williams, Outlines of Chinese Symbolism and Art Motives
(Shanghai: Kelly and Walsh, 1968), 110.
12
Poh, The Christian in the Chinese Culture, 79.
13
Rin Ro Bong, ed, Christian Alternatives to Ancestor Practices
(Taiwan: Asia Theological Association, 1985), 85-6.
14
Poh, The Christian in the Chinese Culture, 117-8.
15
David Hock Tey, Chinese Culture and the Bible (Singapore: Here’s
Life Books, 1988), 79.
16
Albrecht and Singi, A Guidebook for Christians on Taiwanese Custom and
Superstitions, 119.
17
Tong, Ancestral Veneration, 28-9.
18
Tey, Chinese Culture and the Bible, 73.
19 Lit-Sen
Chang, Evangelization Among Buddhist and Confucianists, "Let the Earth
Hear His Voice" (Minneapolis: World Wide Pub, 1975), 839.
20
R.K Harrison, Leviticus, Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries
(Leicester: Inter-Varsity Press, 1980), 196.
21
Poh, The Christian in the Chinese Culture, 41.
22
Tey, Chinese Culture and the Bible, 79.
23
Princeton Hsu, The Bible and Chinese Filial Piety (Hong Kong:
Baptist Press, 1970), 109.
24
Tey, Chinese Culture and the Bible, 82.
25
John J Davis, What About Cremation?: A Christian Perspective
(Winona Lake: BMH Books, 1989), 93-4.
26
John J Davis and John C Whitcomb, A History of Israel: From Conquest to
Exile (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1980), 253.
27 Singapore
Federation of Chinese Clan Associations, Chinese Customs and Festivals
in Singapore (Singapore: Landmark Books, 1989), 63.
28
Ibid., 65.
29
Ibid., 67.
30
Frena Bloomfield, The Book of Chinese Beliefs (London: Arrow Book,
1983), 54.
31
Gailyn Van Rheenen, Communicating Christ in Animistic Contexts
(Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1991), 184.
32
Ibid., 185.
33
Davis and Whitcomb, A History of Israel: From Conquest to Exile,
76.
34
Van Rheenen, Communicating Christ in Animistic Contexts, 185.
35
Hal Lindsey and C C Carlson, Satan is Alive and Well on Planet Earth
(London: Lakeland, 1972), 155.
Rev Tan Eng Boo is pastor of Grace Bible-Presbyterian
Church.
Top
/ Back
|